The Jersey Shore is famous for its breathtaking beaches, bustling boardwalks, and vibrant summer atmosphere. But no trip to the shore is complete without indulging in some of the best ice cream the region has to offer. Whether you’re a local looking for your next go-to spot or a visitor hoping to cool off with a delicious frozen treat, we’ve got you covered. From classic frozen custard stands to unique artisanal flavors, here are the best ice cream spots in the Jersey Shore that you absolutely must try.
1. Hoffman’s Ice Cream & Yogurt
Locations: Point Pleasant, Spring Lake, Little Silver, and Long Branch
Hoffman’s Ice Cream & Yogurt has been a Jersey Shore institution for decades, serving up homemade ice cream made with the freshest ingredients. Originally established in 1955, this beloved shop has perfected its craft, offering unique flavors like Banana, Sea Salt Caramel Latte, and Jersey Monkey. Their generous portion sizes and rich, creamy texture make Hoffman’s a must-visit for ice cream lovers.
Why You Should Visit:
- Over 40 flavors, including classics and unique creations
- Locally sourced, high-quality ingredients
- Family-friendly atmosphere with multiple convenient locations
2. Point Creamery Sundaes
Locations: Point Pleasant
A beloved local favorite, Point Creamery is renowned for its decadent sundaes that combine rich, homemade ice cream with delightful toppings. From classics like the Brownie Sundae to creative options like the Waffle Cone Explosion, each sundae is topped with whipped cream and a cherry for the perfect finishing touch.
Why You Should Visit:
- Indulgent sundaes made with premium homemade ice cream
- Creative combinations and classic favorites to satisfy every craving
- Multiple locations make it convenient to enjoy wherever you are
3. Kohr’s Frozen Custard
Locations: Multiple locations across the Jersey Shore
Kohr’s Frozen Custard is synonymous with the Jersey Shore, having served creamy, flavorful custard since 1919. Their signature Orange Cream swirl is a fan favorite, perfectly balancing tangy citrus with rich vanilla custard. If you’re strolling the boardwalk, a stop at Kohr’s is a tradition that has stood the test of time.
Why You Should Visit:
- Iconic frozen custard known for its smooth texture
- Classic flavors like Chocolate Peanut Butter and Orange Cream
- Rich history and nostalgic boardwalk experience
4. Milk Sugar Love Creamery and Bakeshop
Location: Expanding to Asbury Park in 2025
Milk Sugar Love Creamery is bringing its artisanal approach to Asbury Park, crafting small-batch ice cream using locally sourced ingredients. Their menu features unique flavors like avocado cream and lemon oil, setting them apart from traditional ice cream shops. With an old-fashioned soda shop aesthetic, this creamery is perfect for those looking for something a little different.
Why You Should Visit:
- Artisanal, small-batch ice cream with high-quality ingredients
- Unique flavors you won’t find anywhere else
- Nostalgic soda shop vibe with a modern twist
5. The Music Man Singing Ice Cream Shoppe
Location: Lavallette
If you’re in the mood for dessert after your pizza adventure, The Music Man Singing Ice Cream Shoppe in Lavallette offers a one-of-a-kind experience. Combining live entertainment with delicious ice cream, this spot is perfect for families and those looking for a fun, nostalgic atmosphere.
What to try: Their homemade sundaes and milkshakes are crowd favorites, often served with a side of Broadway-style singing from the staff.
Local tip: Arrive early to get a good seat and enjoy the full performance while indulging in your sweet treat.
Why You Should Visit:
- Classic ice cream parlor experience with table service
- Freshly made waffles paired with ice cream
- A staple of the Margate community for nearly 50 years
The History of Ice Cream at the Jersey Shore
Ice cream has been a staple of the Jersey Shore experience for over a century. The tradition dates back to the early 1900s when boardwalks became popular destinations for summer tourists. Iconic establishments like Kohr’s Frozen Custard helped establish the shore as a prime location for frozen treats. Today, the region continues to embrace this sweet tradition, offering both classic and innovative flavors to satisfy every craving.
How to Plan Your Jersey Shore Ice Cream Tour
To make the most of your ice cream adventure, consider planning a day trip along the Jersey Shore, stopping at multiple locations to try different flavors and styles. Start with a refreshing Italian ice at Strollo’s, indulge in creamy frozen custard at Kohr’s, and end the day with an artisanal creation at Milk Sugar Love. Whether you prefer a traditional cone or an adventurous new flavor, there’s something for everyone.
Planning Your Jersey Shore Vacation
If you’re visiting the Jersey Shore, why not extend your stay with Breezy Beach Stays? Our vacation rentals offer the perfect blend of comfort and convenience, ideally located between Point Pleasant Beach and Seaside Park. Whether you’re looking for a relaxing beachfront retreat or a home base for exploring local attractions, we have the perfect accommodations for you.
Book Your Stay Today and Experience:
Explore Charming Towns
Discover unique shops, restaurants, and entertainment in coastal communities like Point Pleasant Beach and Seaside Park.
Family-Friendly Fun
Enjoy amusement parks, water parks, and mini golf courses that create lasting summer memories.
Outdoor Adventures
Hike scenic trails, kayak through tranquil waterways, or embark on a deep-sea fishing excursion.
Year-Round Attractions
From fall foliage to festive holiday events, the Jersey Shore offers something special in every season.
Why Choose Breezy Beach Stays?
- Quality Accommodations: Our properties are family-friendly and stocked with essentials like towels, linens, and kitchen supplies.
- Flexible Booking: Standard check-in is at 4:00 PM, with options for early check-in or late check-out based on availability.
- Community Support: We encourage guests to explore local events and support small businesses in the area.
Ready to Experience the Best of the Jersey Shore?
Visit our website to browse our selection of single-family homes and cottages, and start planning your dream vacation today!
By exploring the best ice cream spots in the Jersey Shore, you’re not just treating yourself to delicious flavors – you’re also experiencing a time-honored tradition that makes summer at the shore truly unforgettable. Whether you’re enjoying a simple scoop or an elaborate sundae, these local gems are sure to leave you coming back for more.
