The Jersey Shore is more than just a summer destination with beautiful beaches and lively boardwalks – it’s also home to some of the best pizza spots in Jersey Shore. Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style slice, a crispy thin crust, or a unique gourmet pie, this guide will take you through the must-visit pizzerias that have been delighting both locals and visitors for years.

From long-standing institutions to hidden gems, here’s where you’ll find the top pizza spots along the Jersey Shore.

Sawmill Pizza: A Boardwalk Tradition

Since 1977, The Sawmill has been a staple on the Seaside Park boardwalk, serving up some of the best pizza on the shore. Famous for their jumbo slices, Sawmill is a must-visit for any pizza lover looking for a hearty, satisfying meal.

Must-try: The Jumbo Sawmill Pizza slice – it’s not just big, it’s delicious! This oversized slice is perfect for sharing or tackling solo if you’re really hungry.

Fun fact: The Sawmill is the only building on Seaside Park’s boardwalk that survived both Hurricane Sandy in 2012 and the devastating fire of 2013, making it a true local landmark.

Maruca’s Tomato Pies: Seaside Heights’ Swirl Sensation

Maruca’s is famous for its unique tomato pies featuring a signature swirl of sauce atop the cheese. Their distinctive style and fresh ingredients have made them one of the best pizza spots in Jersey Shore.

Must-try: The classic Tomato Pie – its thin crust and flavorful sauce-to-cheese ratio make it a standout dish.

Did you know? Maruca’s has been a Jersey Shore staple since 1950, starting in Trenton before expanding to the boardwalk.

Pete & Elda’s: Neptune City’s Thin Crust Haven

A Jersey Shore institution since 1961, Pete & Elda’s in Neptune City is famous for its extra-thin crust pizzas. Their unique style has earned them a dedicated following and numerous accolades over the years.

Must-try: The XXL pizza challenge – if you can finish an entire extra-large pizza by yourself, you’ll earn a free t-shirt and lifelong bragging rights.

Local tip: Come hungry and be prepared for a wait, especially on weekends. The thin crust means you can eat more slices than you might expect!

Manzano’s Brick Oven Pizza: A Taste of Authentic Italy

Located in Waretown, Manzano’s has recently been crowned the best pizza at the Jersey Shore, and for good reason. This family-owned establishment has been perfecting their craft for over 20 years, offering authentic Italian flavors that keep locals coming back and visitors raving.

What to try: Their brick oven pizzas are a must, featuring bubbling mozzarella and a perfectly crisp crust. The Margherita pizza is a standout, with its simple yet flavorful combination of San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil.

Local insight: Visit on a weekday evening to avoid the weekend rush and enjoy a more relaxed dining experience.

Talula’s: Asbury Park’s Sourdough Sensation

A local favorite in Asbury Park, Talula’s is known for their sourdough pizzas. The owners, Steve and Shanti Mignona, make everything in-house, from cheeses to pickled vegetables. This commitment to quality and creativity has earned them a loyal following among pizza aficionados.

Must-try: The Beekeeper’s Lament, featuring spicy soppressata, fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and a drizzle of honey. The combination of sweet and spicy flavors is truly unforgettable.

Insider’s tip: Don’t skip their homemade gelato for dessert – it’s the perfect way to end your meal.

Rosie’s Pizza: Point Pleasant Beach’s Hidden Gem

Rosie’s is a small, family-run spot that prides itself on using fresh, locally sourced ingredients and traditional techniques to create some of the best pizza in Point Pleasant Beach.

Must-try: The classic Margherita pizza, made with fresh basil and mozzarella, is simple but unforgettable.

Local insight: Get there early! Rosie’s is known for selling out quickly, especially during the summer months.

Vic’s Pizza: Bradley Beach’s Classic Italian Spot

A beloved institution in Bradley Beach, Vic’s has been serving up delicious pizza and Italian dishes since 1947. With its old-school charm and hearty portions, this spot is a local favorite.

What to try: Their thin-crust cheese pizza is legendary, but their white clam pie is a unique option worth trying.

Pro tip: Vic’s is also known for their excellent pasta dishes, so bring a friend and try both!

Pacidough’s: Toms River’s Rising Star

Thanks to a recent rave review from Dave Portnoy, Pacidough’s in Toms River is quickly becoming one of the most talked-about pizza spots on the shore.

Must-try: The signature Vodka Sauce Pizza, which perfectly balances creamy sauce with crispy crust.

Local tip: Pacidough’s tends to get busy after Portnoy’s review, so consider ordering ahead or visiting during off-peak hours.

Experience the Best Pizza Spots in Jersey Shore

These local favorites offer more than just great pizza—they provide a taste of the Jersey Shore’s rich culinary tradition. Each pizzeria has its own unique style and atmosphere, reflecting the diverse character of the shore communities.

From the jumbo slices at Sawmill to the swirled sauce of Maruca’s Tomato Pies, the Jersey Shore pizza scene has something for every palate. Whether you’re a thin-crust enthusiast or a deep-dish devotee, you’ll find a pizza spot that will satisfy your cravings.

Plan Your Pizza Adventure

Ready to embark on your own Jersey Shore pizza tour? Consider booking a stay with Breezy Beach Stays. Our vacation rentals offer the perfect home base for your culinary adventures, allowing you to explore these fantastic pizzerias at your leisure. After a day of sun, sand, and incredible pizza, you’ll have a comfortable place to relax and plan your next slice of paradise.